Set-off of Claims in Judicial Reorganization and Arbitration

A decision by the Brazilian Superior Court of Justice (STJ) ordered the partial annulment of an arbitral award that had ruled on the possibility of setting off claims subject to judicial reorganization, citing harm to other pari passu creditors.

Recently, the STJ issued a decision in Special Appeal No. 2163463 – SP (2024/0300443-0), partially annulling an arbitral award that had authorized the set-off between reciprocal claims of a company undergoing judicial reorganization and one of its creditors.

In this case, the appellant, a company in judicial reorganization (“company under recovery”), challenged an arbitral award that recognized the possibility of setting off reciprocal claims between the debtor and a third party, seeking the partial nullity of that award. The trial court dismissed the claim, arguing that the matter concerned the merits of the arbitral award and could not be reviewed by the Judiciary.

The São Paulo Court of Justice upheld the decision, rejecting the arguments of non-arbitrability and violation of creditor equality, on the grounds that the contractual set-off had occurred before the filing for judicial reorganization. It also considered that the issue of set-off had been duly presented in the arbitral proceedings.

The STJ, however, reversed the appellate court’s ruling and granted the special appeal, grounding its decision on the distinction between objective arbitrability (subject matter of the dispute) and subjective arbitrability (status of the parties). Objective arbitrability, as defined in Article 1 of Law No. 9,307/1996 (Brazilian Arbitration Law), is limited to disputes involving freely disposable property rights. The STJ held that the subjective condition of one of the parties being under judicial reorganization or bankruptcy does not prevent or suspend the initiation of arbitration proceedings (subjective arbitrability, pursuant to Article 6, §9 of the Brazilian Bankruptcy Law).

However, the STJ found that “since set-off constitutes a means of discharging obligations, when it involves claims subject to judicial reorganization, it cannot be regarded as a freely disposable property right, which precludes the resolution of disputes on this matter through arbitration due to the lack of the requirement of objective arbitrability.” It ultimately concluded that the lower court had violated Article 1 of the Arbitration Law. Therefore, the STJ ruled that, as from the granting of the judicial reorganization request, matters related to the satisfaction of claims subject to the collective proceeding must comply with the rules set forth in Law No. 11.101/2005 (Brazilian Bankruptcy Law).

Fungibility  the analysis of the possibility of setting off claims involving a company subject to judicial reorganization falls within the jurisdiction of the reorganization court, which must assess whether the requirements for set-off—namely liquidity, maturity, and fungibility—are present in the specific case, either before or after the filing for judicial reorganization. If these requirements are met prior to the filing, set-off operates automatically, subject to Article 368 of the Brazilian Civil Code. If they arise only after the filing of the reorganization petition, the debtor may not discharge obligations subject to the reorganization through set-off. Thus, the STJ granted the appeal to declare the partial nullity of the arbitral award, pursuant to Article 32, IV of the Arbitration Law, which provides that an arbitral award is null if rendered beyond the limits of the arbitration agreement.

Galante Sociedade de Advogados

This text is for informational purposes only, does not replace individualized legal guidance, nor does it constitute the provision of legal services.